This home sits on three lots on Trabue Street; a single block street in the heart of the Old Historic District of Punta Gorda. This short street was the only memorial to the town's founder, Isaac Trabue, until 2009 when City Council designated public lands east of the Justice Center, along the Harbor, as Trabue Park. The original abstract shows the paving, curbing and storm drainage were put into place in 1925. Fred M. and his wife, Mary Calhoun Johnson, purchased the house in 1931. They passed the house to their son Richard C. and his wife, Jutta. It remained in the Johnson family until 1980. Shortly after the first Johnson family moved in, the porch was closed in to make a bedroom and a half bath. The original floor, china closets, ceilings, baseboards and wainscoting remain throughout the interior.
Punta Gorda History Center Historic Buildings and and Site Records
607 Trabue Street
In 1885, Isaac Trabue and his wife, Virginia, deeded this property to John Cross and John Trabue to be used for a described purpose, mainly to be planted in pineapples, lemons, oranges and other profitable fruit. When the produce was sold, two thirds of the profit was to be used as prizes for a "chess tournament". From 1902 to 1917 Punta Gorda was a principal supplier of pineapples to the nation. By March of 1917, the pineapple fields were gone due to a freeze which ended the 20 year pineapple boom. In 1924, the whole block sold for $4,000 and this house was built soon after. In 1964, the City of Punta Gorda tax on the property was $35.36. At that time, Mr. A. C. Frizzel owned the property. He was a prosperous cattle rancher in the Murdock area. It was occupied for about 30 years by Lois and Ellsworth Heusted.
219 Sullivan Street
"Circuit riding' Reverend George Gatewood bought this home in 1915. He was a minister licensed by the Methodist General conference in 1899. He preached to frontier churches that were beyond the reach of regular clerics with the help of occasional visiting ministers. He attended the spiritual needs of 200 homesteaders in "Union Services" which were held in school houses throughout the area. He and his wife supported themselves by operating "General" stores here in town. He also worked as postmaster, real estate salesman, fisherman and newspaper reporter. He wrote two books of historical significance: "Ox Cart Days to Airplane Era in Southwest Florida" and "On Florida's Coconut Coast" both of which have been republished by the Punta Gorda Historical Society.
252 Marion Avenue - the Johnson Building
A large concrete building on the corner of Sullivan and W. Marion housed many stores over the years. Built by Jesse Sandlin and Dr. Newman. Dr. Newman's dentist's office was there and Josh Mizell had a real estate office with Sandlin. W.H. Johnson later owned it and had his real estate office there, hence the name The Johnson Building. J.T. Griggs had a grocery store on the west side of the building and on the corner was Jones Brothers Meat Market. J.K. McClelland had his Sundry Store and Ice Cream Parlor there for a time. Charlotte County housed its offices from 1921 until the Court House was built. After Jones Brothers and the county offices moved out, Elmer Oswald had a men's store there for years.
Waterfront, Punta Gorda - First Home Site


211 Charlotte Avenue - Sacred Heart Church - original church building
The first celebration of a Catholic mass in what is now Charlotte County is said to have been when Ponce deLeon arrived here in the 1520s, some 500 years ago, but the roots of an actual Sacred Heart Parish start in 1892 when a visiting priest said a Mass in a store at Marion and King Street. A building dedicated to the parish, however, was not constructed until almost 40 years later. Until then services were conducted in the Hotel Charlotte Harbor. The first celebrated Mass at that first Sacred Heart Church sanctuary was at 10 a.m on Christmas morning in 1929. The original church seated 125 parishioners. The little church was replaced in 1965. And that structure after being badly damaged in 2004 by Charley was replaced by the current church building in 2008. The church pictured here seated 125 parishioners.
911 West Marion Avenue
311 Goldstein Street
Built 1920. As of October, 2025 Historic Preservation Board approved demolition due to hurricane damage .
-
Built 1920. As of October, 2025 Historic Preservation Board approved demolition due to hurricane damage .
-
First house in Trabue. The painting of this house now hangs in the home of Terry Runkle. Mrs. McAdow moved from Punta Gorda and gave th...
-
Being demolished after Hurricane Milton 2024. Constructed in 1951 as a one-story, Masonry Vernacular, single-family house, the structure a...




